The Sopranos Season 2 Episode 4: “Commendatori”


“Commendatori” Review

Grade: B+

The Sopranos Go to Italy

“Commendatori” is an episode that is a little worse than I remembered. Once again, this is The Sopranos we’re talking about, so I’m speaking relatively here — “worse” and “bad” aren’t to be taken at face value. Yet this being The Sopranos, a certain level of excellence is still required, or rather, expected.

When I first watched the series, I had originally ranked this episode as a masterpiece. On rewatch, however, it’ll have to settle for being merely “good.” And that ain’t half bad.

“Commendatori” puts the main plot of season two on hold as Tony and the gang travel to Italy for business. Some other possible ire towards this episode: the trip to Italy feels a little forced. For a show so indebted to The Godfather, it is a requirement that the main characters must make a voyage to the motherland at some point. However, there’s no good reason to do it other than the fact that HBO gave them the money, so might as well do it now while season two is still early. As a result, the trip to Italy is an unnatural digression rather than a necessary detour.

The Sopranos in Italy, "Commendatori"

Early in the episode, Tony Soprano nostalgically remarks that his favorite scene in The Godfather Part II is when Vito Corleone returns to Sicily. There is plenty of nostalgia associated with “Commendatori,” being that the characters are about to embark on a pilgrimage to the Mafioso Mecca. Tony remains reserved about the trip, while Carmela feels slighted that she can’t come along. Uncle Junior, who is now under house arrest, reflects on how he will never end up going. The very idea of Italy is sacred to these characters.

When Tony, Chris and Paulie get to Naples, there is a big focus on the new setting. This is location shooting, after all, dip into that budget and treat yourself. Thankfully, director Tim Van Patten never overwhelms us with stylish culture-montage or exotic clichés. He keeps the episode within The Sopranos’ natural, slow-burn aesthetic despite the fact that it takes place 1,000 miles from home. As Tony explained back in Jersey, it’s just a business trip.

And while conducting business, they quickly find out that Italy is far different than what they expected. For one, Don Vittorio (the boss of the Naples family) is senile and handicapped, thus making his daughter (a young woman named Annalisa) the de facto leader. The matriarchal structure makes Tony uncomfortable.

Furthermore, the Italian soldiers are far more unforgiving than their American counterparts. Case in point: a young boy sets off firecrackers without warning, and Furio Giunta (who originally seemed pretty friendly) mercilessly beats the boy in the middle of the street. Tony and Paulie watch in awe.

The business affairs involving Tony and Annalisa aren’t all that important, the main takeaway being that Furio will be sent to Jersey as part of a deal involving luxury cars. Nevertheless, the sexual tension between the two bosses makes the scenes worthwhile. Annalisa reminds Tony of Dr. Melfi, with her psychological quips and probing questions. In turn, she bears a striking resemblance to Isabella, the girl from Tony’s fever dream in season one. In the episode’s finest scene, Tony and Annalisa walk amidst ancient ruins, talking about the Oracle of Delphi, a surreal atmosphere pervading the air.

Big Pussy's wife in "Commendatori"

Back in Jersey, we get a storyline involving the housewives, which is handled surprisingly well for how boring it sounds. The plot mainly focuses on Angie Bonpensiero’s existential crisis in the wake of Big Pussy’s cruelty and neglect. She contemplates suicide and pursues divorce, which is unfairly criticized by the hypocritical Carmela.

Of course, Carmela only fears that these things might someday happen to her. As a guilty Catholic, she wonders if Tony will one day treat her the same way Pussy treats Angie. When Tony returns home from Italy, she sits in the bedroom with a concerning look in her eyes, dejected as she hears “I’m home” booming from downstairs.

In the end, Tony is glad to leave Naples, the Jersey factories along the freeway far more welcoming than the coastal towns on the Mediterranean. Paulie, too, is glad to be back home yet unable to admit that the Italian culture disappointed him at every turn. Chris, meanwhile, spent the entire trip in his hotel room, indulging in a heroin stupor with local prostitutes and junkies. He never gets to see the volcano he was originally so adamant about, and he doesn’t buy Adriana a souvenir until he’s at the airport gift shop in Jersey (on the return flight, nonetheless). The idyllic illusion of Italy has been shattered.

As an episode, “Commendatori” is only a blip in season two’s overall hierarchy, yet it’s still a respectable one-off. The overall entertainment value may be lacking, but it’s never a bad idea to slow things down and develop the characters in an unfamiliar setting.


  • Andrea Bocelli’s “Con te partirò” is used throughout the episode — three times, in fact. Thank God the Sopranos didn’t use some hokey Italian folk music that you might expect to hear in a vacation episode. The song will also end up becoming something like Carmela’s theme song.
  • Chris’ heroin scenes also feature fitting music: spacey Italian trip-hop courtesy of Jovanotti.
  • Another funny Richie Aprile anecdote: during Carmela and Janice’s argument over marriage, Janice remarks that “Richie, because of his years in prison, has a sensitivity to the plight of women.” Take that however you want. Carmela bursts out laughing, winning the argument by default.
  • Some of season one’s rare missteps occurred when the series provided social commentary on Italian-American culture, which resulted in some very on-the-nose moments (e.g. Melfi’s family in “The Legend of Tennessee Moltisanti,” or the entirety of “A Hit Is a Hit“). Series creator David Chase uses the trip to Italy mainly as a metaphor to show American arrogance and Italian vanity.
  • One thing I didn’t understand was the fact that Tony is trying to sell the luxury cars to the Italians for over $100,000. Wouldn’t they know this is an outrageous price right away? I guess the writers just needed any excuse for Tony and co. to go to Italy, no matter how unbelievable and unimportant.
  • “Commendatori” was written by series creator David Chase and directed by Tim Van Patten.


  • “Then he went back to whatever the fuck he was doing.  Spraying WD-40 on his pocket knife.”
  • “If you give this guy a golf club, he’d probably try and fuck it.”
  • “If I want the excitement of Chinese food, I don’t need your permission.”

The Sopranos Season 2 Episode 4: “Commendatori”

One thought on “The Sopranos Season 2 Episode 4: “Commendatori”

  1. Colin, hopefully you’re still around so we can compare notes. And hopefully, too, this Season will be as good as I expect it to be, so that I finish it by this week-end.
    In the meantime I’ll just say ‘What a woman!’

Leave a Reply

Scroll to top