Top 10 Albums of 1954

The 10 Best Albums of 1954

In 1954, John Travolta was born in New Jersey, Lyndon B. Johnson was elected as Senate Majority Leader and Miles Davis made the best album of the year.

After Peggy Lee shattered the Colin’s Review glass ceiling in 1953 by becoming the first woman to earn an Album of the Year acclamation, it should come as no surprise that others would soon follow. However, the process was slow and arduous — not only in terms of Colin’s Review, but within the larger context of the music industry itself. The sad truth is that it wouldn’t be until the 2010s that female musicians properly received the contemporary recognition they deserved. Unfortunately, they just weren’t afforded the same opportunities back in 1954.

As a self-proclaimed music critic, I’m obliged to acknowledge my biases. And that’s why I apologize when I say that there wasn’t a woman (or man) alive who could compare to the musical innovations of Miles Davis in the 1950s. That’s just an objective fact. His famous Birth of the Cool sessions (originally recorded in 1949 and first released as a 10″ LP in 1954) was just the beginning of his artistic dominance.

Nevertheless, it’s great to see Odetta (#10) and Dinah Washington (#8) joining the likes of Billie Holiday, Mary Ford, Ella Fitzgerald, Yma Sumac and the aforementioned Peggy Lee as featured artists on these yearly lists. Standing alongside the likes of Louis Armstrong (#6), Frank Sinatra (#4) and the Clifford Brown & Max Roach duo (#2) is an honor that anyone can be proud of.

And so, without further ado, here are the 10 best albums of 1954.

10. The Tin Angel 


Artist: Odetta & Larry

Genre: Country Blues

Combining influences of folk, country and Gospel spirituals, this underrated LP of salt-of-the-earth blues finds now-famous Odetta partnering with who-the-hell-is-Larry? for lo-fi editions of timeless Lead Belly, enduring Blind Blake and a few classic Woody Guthrie’s.

The rest of the tunes are all traditionals, ranging in origin from the mid-19th century to the early 1940s. More of an artifact than a timeless masterpiece, but an enlightening listen nonetheless.

9. Grand Jacques


Artist: Jacques Brel

Genre: Chanson

Jacques Brel is quite possibly Belgium’s greatest musician ever. Full of humorous candor, Grand Jacques is a debut LP that is wise beyond its years. Continue reading…

8. After Hours with Miss D 


Artist: Dinah Washington

Genre: Vocal Jazz

Washington’s voice is extremely powerful, blending blues, pop and jazz instincts into a singular expression of mass appeal. The music that backs her up often matches her intensity, most notably on the extended version of “Blue Skies.” But I think the organ performance on “Am I Blue” really steals the show.

7. Al Haig Trio (Esoteric)


Artist: Al Haig

Genre: Bebop

On this Al Haig relaxing LP, the usual suspects steal the show: an effervescent rendition of “Moonlight in Vermont,” the serene melancholic phrasings of “Autumn in New York,” and a dreamily upbeat “Body and Soul,” of which the final two minutes reach sublime levels of pianissimo. Continue reading…

6. Louis Armstrong Plays W.C. Handy


Artist: Louis Armstrong

Genre: Dixieland

Out of all the albums released in 1954, Satchmo’s tribute to the influential blues pioneer is by far the most fun. In fact, this may be the most amusing and lighthearted album of the entire decade.

5. A Night at Birdland


Artist: Art Blakey

Genre: Hard Bop

For all my Max Roach praise, Art Blakey’s performance on A Night at Birdland might even surpass the best work that Roach ever recorded. But the proceedings are anchored by Horace Silver, the pianist who pens the concert’s two best tracks: “Split Kick” and “Quicksilver.” Like Jazz at Massey Hall or Ellington at Newport, Art Blakey’s Night at Birdland captures a rarified concert atmosphere that translates perfectly to record.

4. Songs for Young Lovers


Artist: Frank Sinatra

Genre: Swing

Songs for Young Lovers finds Frank Sinatra giving one of the greatest and most tender vocal performances of his career, kickstarting a sustained run of greatness that launched him into the stratosphere of 20th century icons. Continue reading…

3. Thelonious Monk Trio


Artist: Thelonious Monk

Genre: Bebop

Thelonious Monk’s dissonant, slightly off-kilter chord progressions are warm and welcoming despite their occasional harsh atonality. Even in this minimal setting, Monk is able to conjure up a surprising world of sound. Continue reading…

2. Clifford Brown & Max Roach 


Artist: Clifford Brown & Max Roach

Genre: Hard Bop

On this legendary debut, Clifford Brown stakes his claim as the greatest trumpeter alive, yet drummer Max Roach is even more impressive. It’s only because of alphabetical aesthetics that he doesn’t receive top billing. Continuer reading…

1. Birth of the Cool

birth of the cool

Artist: Miles Davis

Genre: Cool Jazz

Recorded in three separate sessions from 1949 to 1950 (and released as a 10” LP in 1954), Birth of the Cool laid the foundations for all major jazz developments in the decade that followed. From the proto-Mingus post-bop of “Israel” to the modal “Moon Dreams” at the album’s center, Davis rewrote the rulebook of what is and isn’t possible. Continue reading…

Top 10 Albums of 1954

Leave a Reply

Scroll to top